The Cost of a Sellers Unrealistic Expectations

by Arnold Pierce Kelsey 27th of May, 2025
The Cost of a Sellers Unrealistic Expectations
The Cost of a Sellers Unrealistic Expectations

Throughout my career as a business broker, I have encountered numerous challenges; however, my most formidable setbacks have consistently arisen from engaging with sellers who maintain unrealistic expectations. 

A particularly illustrative case involved a niche enterprise that I had listed with an asking price of $1,000,000. Although the business exhibited potential, it was hampered by a limited operational history - a fact I recognised would present substantial hurdles in achieving the desired valuation.

I took the initiative to communicate my concerns to the seller, articulating the difficulties we would face in securing such a price without a comprehensive and robust financial track record. 

Nevertheless, I remained optimistic about my ability to emphasise the long-term growth opportunities that could substantiate a premium price for the right buyer.


Buyer Found

 

In my efforts, I successfully attracted several potential buyers; however, only a select few were willing to entertain the long-term possibilities I had outlined. 

After a series of comprehensive discussions, one buyer ultimately agreed to meet the full asking price and terms. 

We proceeded to draft the necessary contracts, which I promptly forwarded to the solicitors for review. Unfortunately, the seller became increasingly unresponsive, even neglecting to return calls from his own legal counsel. 


The ‘Friends’ Advice


Despite my persistent attempts to keep the buyer engaged and informed, the seller, swayed by a friend's unsolicited advice, abruptly declared that the price was insufficient and insisted on raising it to $1,500,000. 

I strongly counselled against this precipitous increase, particularly after we had already reached a mutual agreement.

Nevertheless, I endeavoured to persuade the buyer of the business's long-term viability, leading him to reluctantly agree to the new price point. We amended the contracts accordingly, yet once again, the seller became unreachable. 

After further discussions with his friend, the seller decided to escalate the asking price to an astonishing $2,000,000. I warned him that such a drastic increase would likely alienate the buyer, who ultimately withdrew his offer, citing the seller's unethical conduct as the primary reason for his decision.


Withdrawing from the Market


As a result, the business languished on the market for several months without garnering any interest. 

I promptly advised the seller that without improved financial performance, we were at an impasse. 

Upon reviewing the most recent financial figures, it became glaringly evident that the business had suffered a significant decline, now realistically valued at only a few hundred thousand dollars. 

Ultimately, the seller chose to withdraw the listing from the market.


Liquidation


Six months later, I encountered another prospective buyer interested in a business of this nature.

I reached out to the seller to ascertain the current status of the enterprise. He conveyed that the business was facing severe financial distress and was undergoing liquidation. 

With palpable regret, he acknowledged his failure to heed my professional advice and accept the $1,500,000 offer when it was on the table.


Setting Realistic Expectations


This experience profoundly underscored the critical importance of maintaining realistic expectations and being open to professional guidance.

As a business broker, my primary role is to provide an objective assessment of market conditions and to navigate sellers through the intricate complexities of the business landscape. 

Unrealistic expectations not only hinder progress but can lead to significant missed opportunities, as demonstrated in this regrettable case.

Tags: business broker tips selling

About the author


Arnold Pierce Kelsey

Business Broker

Multiple award winning business broker.

As a distinguished multimillion-dollar transaction expert, Arnold demonstrates profound proficiency in ...

view profile


Related Articles

Lessons from Ken Allsop’s 25 Years as a Business Broker

28 April 2025

Lessons from Ken Allsop’s 25 Years as a Business Broker

With a business career spanning over 50 years (and still going strong), you would expect Ken Allsop, the director...

Merchant Business Brokers Celebrates Their Best Year!

24 April 2025

Merchant Business Brokers Celebrates Their Best Year!

The 2024 financial year was our biggest yet, marking five consecutive years of growth. We worked hard to connect...

Ray Dye: A Business Broker’s Journey of Trust, Relationships and Realism

30 September 2024

Ray Dye: A Business Broker’s Journey of Trust, Relationships and Realism

With a career spanning three continents and three unique business environments, Ray Dye brings diverse experie...

From Past to Present: The New Challenges and Opportunities for a Business Broker

5 August 2024

From Past to Present: The New Challenges and Opportunities for a Business Broker

Being a business broker has undergone significant changes over the past 30-40 years. While some aspects of the...